===========  Review Form  =========== 

Paper ID: 
Author(s): 
Title: 

Recommendation to Editors with A-D: 
A. Accept
B. Accept with minor changes
C. Accept with major changes
D. Reject

Please, fill the following items with 1-5
(5 =Excellent, 4=Very Good, 3=Good, 2=Fair, 1=None)

****. Relevance to the Journal: 
****. Originality: 
****. Significance of Contribution: 
****. Technical Soundness: 
****. Quality of Presentation: 
****. Paper Length: 
****. Title Appropriate: 
****. Abstract Adequate: 
****. Paper Organization: 
****. Number of References: 
****. Confidence in your Assessment: 

Detailed comments to Authors: 



Detailed Comments to Editors: 



---------------------------
Date: 
Reviewer name: 
Reviewer institution: 
Reviewer email: 
Reviewer name remains anonymous by default. Would you like us to expose your name to the authors? (Y/N):